Now accepting Telehealth appointments. Schedule a virtual visit.

The Benefit of Colonoscopy

The Benefit of Colonoscopy

Colonoscopy remains best and proven way to detect and
prevent colorectal cancer and colorectal cancer deaths

The American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy (ASGE) is stressing that colonoscopy, using modern endoscopy methods performed according to clinical guidelines, is still the best and most proven way for patients to be screened for colorectal cancer following the release of a Nordic-European Initiative on Colorectal Cancer (NordICC) trial report that was released on October 9 in The New England Journal of Medicine.

“Based on available studies today, colonoscopy is still the gold standard in detecting and preventing colorectal cancer, especially for high-risk individuals," says ASGE President Bret Petersen, M.D., MASGE. “Of course, a colonoscopy will only work if a patient gets one – and keeping in mind that just 42 percent of the patients from Norway and Poland who were randomized to screening colonoscopy in the NordICC trial actually underwent the procedure.”

The NordICC report suggests that the benefits associated with a colonoscopy are less than anticipated based on previous case-control and cohort studies and it is noted in the report that the study likely underestimated the benefit of colonoscopy.

Dr. Petersen emphasizes that the quality of colonoscopies varies across the globe depending on physician skillset and training, as well as availability of endoscopy tools and technology. Dr. Petersen explains, “Nearly 30 percent of the endoscopists who were included in the NordICC trial did not meet the adenoma detection rate (ADR) of 25 percent that is recommended in the U.S. – while the ADR average in the U.S. is above 40 percent.”

ASGE Immediate-past President Douglas Rex, M.D., MASGE, has several concerns about the study as well. He says, “There was essentially no shift to earlier stage cancers in the screen detected cancers, something almost never seen in screening studies. Further, the incidence reduction in the per protocol analysis was three times higher in Norway than Poland, suggesting that in Poland either high risk or symptomatic patients could have been overrepresented in the colonoscopy group. Plus, there is no analysis of proximal versus distal cancer incidence, which adds to the challenges of understanding the effect of colonoscopy compared to sigmoidoscopy. Additionally, the higher reduction in cancer incidence compared to the mortality reduction in the intent to screen analysis is concerning and unexplained.”

Dr. Petersen concludes that, “In the per protocol analysis, which considers the persons who actually had colonoscopy, there was a 50 percent reduction in mortality. This is consistent with the overwhelming evidence from case control and cohort studies that colonoscopy prevents colorectal cancer and related deaths. This new study has too many unexplained issues to change the consensus regarding the benefit of colonoscopy. Colonoscopy, using modern endoscopy techniques and trained endoscopists, continues to be the single most important, proven and effective way to detect and prevent colorectal cancer.”

Read More About This Article →


Article From ASGE
Colonoscopy remains best and proven way to detect and prevent colorectal cancer and colorectal cancer deaths
Link: https://www.asge.org/home/about-asge/newsroom/news-list/2022/10/10/colonoscopy-remains-best-and-proven-way-to-detect-and-prevent-colorectal-cancer-and-colorectal-cancer-deaths?_zs=io0E8&_zl=AOsH3

You Might Also Enjoy...

What Can Be Done About My Severe Constipation?

What Can Be Done About My Severe Constipation?

Constipation is a common issue, but that doesn’t make it any less uncomfortable. Besides, it can sometimes indicate a serious ailment. Read on to learn about the causes and treatments of severe constipation.
The Link Between Hepatitis C and Abdominal Pain

The Link Between Hepatitis C and Abdominal Pain

Do you often feel a sharp pain in the right-hand side of your body? Tummy pain is a symptom of many ailments, but in some cases, it could be a sign of a hepatitis C infection. Read on to learn more about the link between the two.
Why Do I Have Diarrhea Frequently?

Why Do I Have Diarrhea Frequently?

Are you always on the lookout for a restroom? Diarrhea could be causing more than mildly uncomfortable behaviors. Read on to learn about the causes of diarrhea and when is time to give your doctor a call.
Eliminating Your Fears About a Colonoscopy

Eliminating Your Fears About a Colonoscopy

A colonoscopy can be life-saving, and in many cases, it can catch polyps even before they become cancerous. But if you still have fears and anxieties about it, read on as our experts address all of your concerns.

My Body Is Dependent on Laxatives: Is That Bad?

Constant constipation may leave you no choice but to use laxatives regularly, but what does that do in the long term? Read on to find out the effects of overusing laxatives and what you can do to have normal bowel movements.